Week 4 · Sunday, October 4, 1:00 PM ET · Final ARI 24, NYG 36
Arizona Cardinals at New York Giants
Giants −2.5 at our first look, +2.5 at kickoff. 12 injury reports on file.
Conditions · MetLife Stadium: Forecast 66°F, wind 8 mph, 52% chance of rain. At kickoff: 60°F, wind 8 mph, dry. The rain in the forecast didn't fall.
The read at kickoff
News: Cardinals 0.0 · Giants +0.6 → favors the Giants by 0.6. Market: moved 5 toward the Cardinals. Never priced in
Landed: Cardinals 24, Giants 36. The Giants covered the closing line (Giants +2.5). The move toward the Cardinals was wrong. 60 points, over the closing total of 44.5.
Arizona Cardinals 0.0
New York Giants +0.6
| S Tyler Nubin Out → Questionable |
Active | +0.5 |
| CB Deonte Banks Out → Questionable |
Active | +0.3 |
| LB Brian Burns Active → Questionable → Out → IR |
IR | −0.2 |
Each player counted once: his whole week, first status to last, in points from his team's side (−0.9 costs his team 0.9). A unit missing two or three starters counts extra. After the inactive list, a questionable starter who isn't on it is playing.
Line Movement
Final: ARI 24, NYG 36. Giants beat the closing number by 14.5.
Data
| Cause | When | Move |
|---|---|---|
| Opening line | −2.5 | |
| NYG LB Burns to injured reserve | Sun Sep 27, 7:47 PM ET | +2.5 |
| Reaction to last week's game | Sun Sep 27, 7:47 PM ET | +1.5 |
| Giants Cutting Veteran Receiver Beckham | Tue Sep 29, 4:49 PM ET | +0.5 |
| NYG LT Thomas questionable | Wed Sep 30, 4:29 PM ET | +0.5 |
| Closing line | +2.5 |
Final: ARI 24, NYG 36. Giants won at a 44% closing chance to win.
Data
| Cause | When | Move |
|---|---|---|
| Opening line | 55.9% (−127) | |
| NYG LB Burns to injured reserve | Sun Sep 27, 7:47 PM ET | 51.0% (−104) |
| Reaction to last week's game | Sun Sep 27, 7:47 PM ET | 48.1% (+108) |
| Giants Cutting Veteran Receiver Beckham | Tue Sep 29, 4:49 PM ET | 47.1% (+112) |
| NYG LT Thomas questionable | Wed Sep 30, 4:29 PM ET | 45.8% (+118) |
| Price-only move | 44.4% (+125) | |
| Closing line | 44.4% (+125) |
Final: ARI 24, NYG 36. 60 points, over the closing total of 44.5.
Data
| Cause | When | Move |
|---|---|---|
| Opening line | 44.5 | |
| NYG LT Thomas questionable | Thu Oct 1, 1:42 PM ET | -0.5 |
| ARI EDGE Sweat questionable | Sat Oct 3, 12:14 PM ET | +0.5 |
| Closing line | 44.5 |
Notes
Giants Beat Cardinals 36–24
Final: Arizona Cardinals 24, New York Giants 36. New York won outright as the underdog; the closing line was Giants +2.5. The 60 combined points went over the closing total of 44.5.
NYG since this note: +2.5 → +2.5 (no move) at kickoff
Cardinals Call Up Rookie Robertson With Sweat In Doubt
Arizona elevated rookie outside linebacker Cameron Robertson from the practice squad for Sunday's game at the Giants, with pass rusher Josh Sweat listed as questionable. Robertson could make his NFL debut if Sweat cannot go, thinning the Cardinals' edge rotation. Arizona Cardinals (team site)
ARI since this note: −2.5 → −2.5 (no move) at kickoff
Line moves 1.5 toward the Cardinals ahead of the news
The consensus spread on Cardinals at Giants has moved from +1 to +2.5 (home side), with 8 of 11 books moving the same way (a broad, fast move). The market started moving 0h 20m before the report: Brian Burns (LB) Out to IR.
NYG since this note: +1.5 → +2.5 (+1.0) at kickoff
Giants Cutting Veteran Receiver Beckham
New York is releasing wide receiver Odell Beckham Jr., according to reports. The move removes a veteran from the receiving rotation ahead of Sunday's home game with Arizona. ESPN
NYG since this note: +1 → +2.5 (+1.5) at kickoff
Rain Chance for Cardinals at Giants
The forecast for kickoff at MetLife Stadium calls for a 52% chance of rain. Forecasts change; this note updates as the game gets closer.
Giants Confirm Winston Stays Starting Quarterback After McCarthy Trade
The Giants' head coach said Jameis Winston remains the starting quarterback despite the trade for J.J. McCarthy. That settles the quarterback question for the upcoming game against Arizona. ESPN player news
NYG since this note: +1 → +2.5 (+1.5) at kickoff
McCarthy dealt to New York as Giants add quarterback
Quarterback J.J. McCarthy has been traded from Minnesota to the Giants, per commentary on the move. The change affects the quarterback depth chart for both clubs ahead of Week 4. ESPN
NYG since this note: +1 → +2.5 (+1.5) at kickoff
Line moves 1.5 toward the Cardinals after last week's results
The consensus spread on Cardinals at Giants has moved from −0.5 to +1 (home side), with 6 of 10 books moving the same way. The move began within hours of the teams' last games: the market re-rating them on what it just saw, not a news story.
NYG since this note: −1 → +2.5 (+3.5) at kickoff
Line moves 2.25 toward the Cardinals after last week's results
The consensus spread on Cardinals at Giants has moved from −1.25 to +1 (home side), with 8 of 10 books moving the same way (a broad, fast move). The move began within hours of the teams' last games: the market re-rating them on what it just saw, not a news story.
NYG since this note: −1 → +2.5 (+3.5) at kickoff
Injury Report
Arizona Cardinals
| Player | Change | Worth | Played |
|---|---|---|---|
| LB Mack Wilson Sr. Wed 8:36 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.1 | — |
| DT Roy Lopez Wed 8:36 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.1 | — |
| DT Walter Nolen III Wed 8:36 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.2 | — |
| C Hjalte Froholdt Wed 8:36 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.1 | — |
| EDGE Josh Sweat Fri 5:40 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.2 | — |
| EDGE Josh Sweat Sun 11:45 AM |
Questionable → Cleared | −0.2 | — |
New York Giants
| Player | Change | Worth | Played |
|---|---|---|---|
| LB Brian Burns Sun 4:03 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.1 | — |
| LB Brian Burns Mon 4:07 PM |
Questionable → Out | +0.2 | — |
| S Tyler Nubin Tue 1:06 PM |
Out → Questionable | −0.3 | — |
| CB Deonte Banks Tue 1:06 PM |
Out → Questionable | −0.2 | — |
| LB Brian Burns Tue 5:09 PM |
Out → IR | 0.0 | — |
| LT Andrew Thomas Wed 4:32 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.3 | — |
Worth = points against the team from that change in his chance of playing, on our valuation of him over his backup.
Every Book · Giants side
| Book | Spread | Price | Moneyline | Decimal | Win % (no-vig) | Total | As of |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Consensus | +2.5 | −109 | +116 | 2.16 | 44.4% | 44.5 | Sun 12:54 PM |
| Kalshi | +2.5 | — | +125 | 2.25 | 44.5% | 44 | Sun 12:32 PM |
| DraftKings | +2.5 | −110 | +114 | 2.14 | 44.9% | 44.5 | Sun 12:54 PM |
| FanDuel | +2.5 | −115 | +110 | 2.10 | 45.7% | 43.5 | Sun 12:54 PM |
| BetMGM | +2.5 | −110 | +115 | 2.15 | 44.4% | 44 | Sun 12:54 PM |
| Caesars | +2.5 | −109 | +116 | 2.16 | 44.5% | 44.5 | Sun 12:54 PM |
| Fanatics | +2.5 | −110 | +115 | 2.15 | 44.4% | 44 | Sun 12:54 PM |
| BetRivers | +2.5 | −109 | +116 | 2.16 | 44.3% | 44.5 | Sun 12:54 PM |
| BetOnline | +2.5 | −110 | +119 | 2.19 | 44.0% | 44.5 | Sun 12:54 PM |
| Bovada | +2 | −105 | +120 | 2.20 | 43.8% | 44 | Sun 12:54 PM |
| LowVig | +2.5 | −109 | +119 | 2.19 | 44.0% | 44.5 | Sun 12:54 PM |
| MyBookie | +2.5 | −105 | +116 | 2.16 | 44.5% | 44.5 | Sun 12:54 PM |
| BetUS | +2 | −105 | +120 | 2.20 | 43.8% | 44 | Sun 12:54 PM |
Best for ARI: FanDuel −2.5 (−105)Best for NYG: Caesars +2.5 (−109)
Closing prices: the last quote before kickoff. Kalshi's percentage is its contract price; its odds are that price with no margin. The Cardinals side is the mirror image.