Week 5 · Sunday, October 11, 1:00 PM ET · Final NYG 27, WAS 27
New York Giants at Washington Commanders
Commanders −2.5 at our first look, −3.5 at kickoff. 20 injury reports on file. Team pages: Giants · Commanders
Conditions · Northwest Stadium: Forecast 66°F, wind 13 mph (gusts 29), 85% chance of rain. At kickoff: 63°F, wind 11 mph (gusts 24), rain. It rained.
The read at kickoff
News: Giants −0.3 · Commanders +1.4 → favors the Commanders by 1.8. Market: moved 1 toward the Commanders. Partly priced in
Landed: Giants 27, Commanders 27. The Giants covered the closing line (Commanders −3.5). The move toward the Commanders was wrong. 54 points, over the closing total of 41.5.
New York Giants −0.3
| EDGE Chauncey Golston Active → Questionable → Out → IR |
IR | −0.3 |
Washington Commanders +1.4
| QB Jayden Daniels Out → Questionable |
Active | +3.2 |
| QB Marcus Mariota Active → Doubtful |
Doubtful | −2.4 |
| WR Terry McLaurin Out → Questionable → Cleared |
Active | +0.6 |
| G Sam Cosmi Out → Questionable |
Active | +0.4 |
| WR Stefon Diggs Active → Questionable → Out |
Out | −0.4 |
Each player counted once: his whole week, first status to last, in points from his team's side (−0.9 costs his team 0.9). A unit missing two or three starters counts extra. A questionable starter counts at his chance of sitting (shown beside him with his full value if he's ruled out). After the inactive list, a questionable starter who isn't on it is playing.
Line Movement
Final: NYG 27, WAS 27. Commanders missed the closing number by 3.5.
Data
| Cause | When | Move |
|---|---|---|
| Opening line | −2.5 | |
| Daniels aiming to return at QB for Commanders against Giants | Sun Oct 4, 6:26 PM ET | -1 |
| Daniels cleared without limits for Washington's game against Giants | Thu Oct 8, 2:13 PM ET | -0.5 |
| Nabers back at Giants practice in limited role | Fri Oct 9, 7:00 PM ET | +0.5 |
| Closing line | −3.5 |
Final: NYG 27, WAS 27. Commanders lost at a 62% closing chance to win.
Data
| Cause | When | Move |
|---|---|---|
| Opening line | 56.3% (−129) | |
| Daniels aiming to return at QB for Commanders against Giants | Sun Oct 4, 6:26 PM ET | 62.8% (−169) |
| Daniels cleared without limits for Washington's game against Giants | Thu Oct 8, 2:13 PM ET | 64.6% (−182) |
| Nabers back at Giants practice in limited role | Fri Oct 9, 7:00 PM ET | 62.8% (−169) |
| Less than the spread implies | 62.3% (−165) | |
| Closing line | 62.3% (−165) |
Final: NYG 27, WAS 27. 54 points, over the closing total of 41.5.
Data
| Cause | When | Move |
|---|---|---|
| Opening line | 43.5 | |
| NYG EDGE Golston to injured reserve | Sun Oct 4, 6:26 PM ET | +0.5 |
| WAS QB Mariota doubtful | Mon Oct 5, 12:49 PM ET | -0.5 |
| WAS S Cross upgraded | Wed Oct 7, 5:26 PM ET | -0.5 |
| NYG LT Thomas questionable | Wed Oct 7, 5:26 PM ET | -1 |
| WAS WR Diggs ruled out | Fri Oct 9, 2:20 PM ET | -0.5 |
| Closing line | 41.5 |
Notes
Giants Tie Commanders 27–27
Final: New York Giants 27, Washington Commanders 27. The closing line was Commanders −3.5; New York covered by 3.5. The 54 combined points went over the closing total of 41.5.
NYG since this note: +3.5 → +3.5 (no move) at kickoff
Washington waives rookie back Allen to clear roster spot
The Commanders waived sixth-round rookie running back Kaytron Allen, opening a roster spot likely for one of the three players whose practice windows were opened. The move is depth-level and does not change the starting lineup against the Giants. ProFootballTalk
WAS since this note: −4 → −3.5 (+0.5) at kickoff
Nabers back at Giants practice in limited role
Malik Nabers, who sat out Wednesday with knee soreness, returned on a limited basis Thursday. Left tackle Andrew Thomas was also limited, pointing toward both trending toward availability at Washington. ProFootballTalk
NYG since this note: +4 → +3.5 (−0.5) at kickoff
Daniels cleared without limits for Washington's game against Giants
Washington's offensive coordinator said Thursday that Jayden Daniels is fully cleared and will have no restrictions with his left elbow for Sunday against the Giants. That settles the quarterback situation after a week of uncertainty. ESPN player news
WAS since this note: −3.5 → −3.5 (no move) at kickoff
Nabers misses Giants' first practice of the week
Malik Nabers did not take part in the Giants' opening practice of the week ahead of the trip to Washington. His absence puts his availability for Sunday in doubt and would thin New York's passing game. ProFootballTalk
NYG since this note: +3.5 → +3.5 (no move) at kickoff
Daniels throws at Wednesday practice, trending toward Giants start
Jayden Daniels, dealing with an elbow injury, was seen throwing during the open portion of Washington's Wednesday practice and is listed questionable. With Marcus Mariota sidelined by a knee sprain, his availability is central to the Commanders' plan against the Giants. ESPN player news
WAS since this note: −3.5 → −3.5 (no move) at kickoff
Mariota avoids IR, knee injury seen as short-term
Washington will not place Marcus Mariota on injured reserve despite his knee sprain, meaning he could return within a few weeks. He is doubtful for Sunday against the Giants, leaving the quarterback job to Jayden Daniels or another backup. ESPN player news
WAS since this note: −3.5 → −3.5 (no move) at kickoff
Commanders open practice window for Amos, Wise, McNichols
Washington designated cornerback Trey Amos, defensive end Deatrich Wise and running back Jeremy McNichols to return from injured lists, starting their practice windows. Each could be activated in the coming weeks, adding depth on defense and in the backfield. ProFootballTalk
WAS since this note: −3.5 → −3.5 (no move) at kickoff
Giants add QB Jake Haener to active roster
New York is signing quarterback Jake Haener to its 53-man roster, giving the team three quarterbacks. The move adds depth behind the current starter heading into the Washington game. ProFootballTalk
NYG since this note: +3.5 → +3.5 (no move) at kickoff
Commanders audition QB Jack Plummer amid depth concerns
Washington brought in quarterback Jack Plummer for a workout as it surveys the market. The move follows uncertainty at the position with Marcus Mariota hurt and Jayden Daniels' status in question for Sunday against the Giants. ProFootballTalk
WAS since this note: −3.5 → −3.5 (no move) at kickoff
Berrios out for season after foot surgery decision
Giants returner Braxton Berrios said he needs surgery on his foot and ankle, which ends his season. New York will need another option on kick and punt returns. ProFootballTalk
NYG since this note: +3.5 → +3.5 (no move) at kickoff
Quinn eyes Daniels return at QB for Sunday vs. Giants
Dan Quinn said Washington expects Jayden Daniels to practice fully this week and start against the Giants after an elbow injury. That would return the Commanders' starting quarterback in place of the backup options. ESPN player news
WAS since this note: −3.5 → −3.5 (no move) at kickoff
Mariota diagnosed with sprained MCL, timeline uncertain
Washington coach Dan Quinn said Mariota has a sprained MCL in his right knee with no set recovery timeline. The quarterback is doubtful, clouding Washington's situation under center. ESPN player news
WAS since this note: −3.5 → −3.5 (no move) at kickoff
Giants to place Berrios on injured reserve with foot injury
New York is putting returner and depth receiver Braxton Berrios on injured reserve because of a foot injury. That sidelines him at least four games, costing the Giants their main return man starting with the trip to Washington. ProFootballTalk
NYG since this note: +3.5 → +3.5 (no move) at kickoff
Commanders receiver Lane suffers fractured, dislocated ankle
Washington wideout Jaylin Lane reportedly broke and dislocated his ankle in the loss to Indianapolis. The severity points to a long absence, thinning a receiver group already missing Terry McLaurin. ProFootballTalk
WAS since this note: −3.5 → −3.5 (no move) at kickoff
Line moves 1 toward the Commanders after last week's results
The consensus spread on Giants at Commanders has moved from −2.5 to −3.5 (home side). The move began within hours of the teams' last games: the market re-rating them on what it just saw, not a news story.
WAS since this note: −3.5 → −3.5 (no move) at kickoff
Daniels aiming to return at QB for Commanders against Giants
Jayden Daniels is set to practice fully this week as he recovers from an elbow injury and is targeting a return for Week 5 against the Giants. That would put Washington's starting quarterback back after backup duty was needed in London. ESPN player news
WAS since this note: −2.5 → −3.5 (−1.0) at kickoff
Wind in the Forecast for Giants at Commanders
The forecast for kickoff at Northwest Stadium calls for wind 13 mph, gusting 29, a 85% chance of rain. Forecasts change; this note updates as the game gets closer.
Total since this forecast: 43.5 → 41.5 (−2.0) at kickoff
Mariota faces tests on aggravated MCL sprain
Mariota will undergo further testing after aggravating the right MCL sprain he first suffered in the preseason, which knocked him out of the London game. That puts his availability for Washington's next game in doubt with Jayden Daniels already sidelined. ESPN player news
WAS since this note: −2.5 → −3.5 (−1.0) at kickoff
Injury Report
New York Giants
| Player | Change | Worth | Played |
|---|---|---|---|
| EDGE Chauncey Golston Sun 3:26 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.1 | No |
| WR Malik Nabers Wed 3:44 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.1 | Yes |
| TE Isaiah Likely Wed 4:45 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.0 | Yes |
| RB Cam Skattebo Wed 4:45 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.1 | Yes |
| LT Andrew Thomas Wed 5:46 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.3 | Yes |
| EDGE Chauncey Golston Wed 9:31 PM |
Questionable → Out | +0.2 | No |
| EDGE Chauncey Golston Sat 5:05 PM |
Out → IR | 0.0 | No |
Washington Commanders
| Player | Change | Worth | Played |
|---|---|---|---|
| QB Marcus Mariota Mon 1:15 PM |
Active → Doubtful | +2.4 | No |
| WR Terry McLaurin Tue 2:54 PM |
Out → Questionable | −0.4 | Yes |
| G Sam Cosmi Tue 2:54 PM |
Out → Questionable | −0.3 | Yes |
| S Nick Cross Tue 2:54 PM |
Out → Questionable | −0.3 | No |
| QB Jayden Daniels Tue 2:54 PM |
Out → Questionable | −2.0 | Yes |
| WR Stefon Diggs Wed 1:41 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.1 | No |
| RB Jacory Croskey-Merritt Wed 4:25 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.0 | Yes |
| LB Sonny Styles Wed 5:26 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.2 | Yes |
| LB Frankie Luvu Wed 5:26 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.1 | Yes |
| S Nick Cross Thu 8:32 PM |
Active → Questionable | +0.2 | No |
| WR Stefon Diggs Fri 3:55 PM |
Questionable → Out | +0.3 | No |
| S Nick Cross Fri 5:58 PM |
Questionable → Out | +0.3 | No |
| WR Terry McLaurin Sun 11:56 AM |
Questionable → Cleared | −0.2 | Yes |
Worth = points against the team from that change in his chance of playing, on our valuation of him over his backup.
Every Book · Commanders side
| Book | Spread | Price | Moneyline | Decimal | Win % (no-vig) | Total | As of |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Consensus | −3.5 | −105 | −185 | 1.54 | 62.3% | 41.5 | Sun 12:57 PM |
| Kalshi | −3 | — | −167 | 1.60 | 62.5% | 41 | Sun 12:57 PM |
| DraftKings | −3.5 | −105 | −180 | 1.56 | 61.6% | 41.5 | Sun 12:57 PM |
| FanDuel | −3.5 | −105 | −172 | 1.58 | 60.7% | 41.5 | Sun 12:57 PM |
| BetMGM | −3.5 | −102 | −185 | 1.54 | 61.9% | 41 | Sun 12:57 PM |
| Caesars | −3.5 | −107 | −190 | 1.53 | 62.7% | 41.5 | Sun 12:57 PM |
| Fanatics | −3.5 | −105 | −180 | 1.56 | 61.6% | 41.5 | Sun 12:57 PM |
| BetRivers | −3.5 | −113 | −186 | 1.54 | 61.7% | 41.5 | Sun 12:57 PM |
| BetOnline | −3.5 | −105 | −185 | 1.54 | 62.9% | 40.5 | Sun 12:57 PM |
| Bovada | −3.5 | +100 | −185 | 1.54 | 62.8% | 41 | Sun 12:57 PM |
| LowVig | −3.5 | +101 | −185 | 1.54 | 62.9% | 41 | Sun 12:57 PM |
| MyBookie | −3.5 | +100 | −187 | 1.53 | 62.6% | 41.5 | Sun 12:57 PM |
| BetUS | −3 | −120 | −180 | 1.56 | 62.1% | 41 | Sun 12:57 PM |
| polymarket | −3.5 | −108 | −170 | 1.59 | 62.3% | 42.5 | Thu 4:53 AM |
Best for NYG: BetRivers +3.5 (−108)Best for WAS: BetMGM −3.5 (−102)
Closing prices: the last quote before kickoff. Kalshi's percentage is its contract price; its odds are that price with no margin. The Giants side is the mirror image.