0 reports filed today
Every book · every report · every result
The news that moves games, and whether the market has priced it in
Tuesday, November 3, 2026 Week 8 · Final Edition

Back issue · The Sharp Edition, Week 8 as it stood when the week closed.

Week 6 · Sunday, October 18, 1:00 PM ET · Final NO 34, NYG 27

New Orleans Saints at New York Giants

Giants +1.5 at our first look, +1 at kickoff. 19 injury reports on file. Team pages: Saints · Giants

Conditions · MetLife Stadium: Forecast 56°F, wind 6 mph, 0% chance of rain. At kickoff: 57°F, wind 3 mph, dry.

The read at kickoff

News: Saints +0.6 · Giants −0.9 → favors the Saints by 1.5. Market: moved 0.5 toward the Giants. Never priced in

Landed: Saints 34, Giants 27. The Saints covered the closing line (Giants +1). The move toward the Giants was wrong. 61 points, over the closing total of 46.5.

New Orleans Saints +0.6

EDGE Vernon Broughton
Out → Questionable
Active+0.6

New York Giants −0.9

S Tyler Nubin
Active → Questionable → Out
Out−0.5
RT Jermaine Eluemunor
Active → Questionable → Out
Out−0.4

Each player counted once: his whole week, first status to last, in points from his team's side (−0.9 costs his team 0.9). A unit missing two or three starters counts extra. A questionable starter counts at his chance of sitting (shown beside him with his full value if he's ruled out). After the inactive list, a questionable starter who isn't on it is playing.

Line Movement

What moved the Giants lineNew York Giants spread, consensus of U.S. books and Kalshi. Right = against New York.
−1PK+1+2Opening line+1.5Market move, no reported newsWed 5:26 PM−2.4NYG RT Eluemunor ruled outSun 10:12 AMmarket moved 5h before the report+0.5NO EDGE Broughton upgradedTue 11:21 AMmarket moved 2h before the report+0.6NO LB Elliss upgradedTue 11:21 AMmarket moved 2h before the report+0.4NO WR Olave questionableThu 5:09 PM−0.7NYG S Nubin ruled outThu 7:46 PMmarket moved 22h before the report+0.6NO LB Elliss ruled outFri 7:01 AMmarket moved 8h before the report−0.5Olave back at practice,questionable for Saints at GiantsSat 12:00 PM+0.5NO RB Kamara activeSun 10:54 AM+0.5Closing line+1
−1PK+1+2Opening line+1.5Market move, no reported newsWed 5:26 PM−2.4NYG RT Eluemunor ruled outSun 10:12 AM · market moved 5h before the report+0.5NO EDGE Broughton upgradedTue 11:21 AM · market moved 2h before the report+0.6NO LB Elliss upgradedTue 11:21 AM · market moved 2h before the report+0.4NO WR Olave questionableThu 5:09 PM−0.7NYG S Nubin ruled outThu 7:46 PM · market moved 22h before the report+0.6NO LB Elliss ruled outFri 7:01 AM · market moved 8h before the report−0.5Olave back at practice, questionable forSaints at GiantsSat 12:00 PM+0.5NO RB Kamara activeSun 10:54 AM+0.5Closing line+1

Final: NO 34, NYG 27. Giants missed the closing number by 6.

Data
CauseWhenMove
Opening line+1.5
Market move, no reported newsWed Oct 7, 5:26 PM ET-2.4
NYG RT Eluemunor ruled outSun Oct 11, 10:12 AM ET+0.5
NO EDGE Broughton upgradedTue Oct 13, 11:21 AM ET+0.6
NO LB Elliss upgradedTue Oct 13, 11:21 AM ET+0.4
NO WR Olave questionableThu Oct 15, 5:09 PM ET-0.7
NYG S Nubin ruled outThu Oct 15, 7:46 PM ET+0.6
NO LB Elliss ruled outFri Oct 16, 7:01 AM ET-0.5
Olave back at practice, questionable for Saints at GiantsSat Oct 17, 12:00 PM ET+0.5
NO RB Kamara activeSun Oct 18, 10:54 AM ET+0.5
Closing line+1
What moved the Giants moneylineNew York Giants moneyline, no-vig consensus of U.S. books and Kalshi. Right = toward New York.
+108+104−100−104−108−113Opening line+108Market move, no reported newsWed 5:26 PM−111NYG RT Eluemunor ruled outSun 10:12 AMmarket moved 5h before the report−106NO EDGE Broughton upgradedTue 11:21 AMmarket moved 2h before the report−102NO LB Elliss upgradedTue 11:21 AMmarket moved 2h before the report+101NO WR Olave questionableThu 5:09 PM−104NYG S Nubin ruled outThu 7:46 PMmarket moved 22h before the report+100NO LB Elliss ruled outFri 7:01 AMmarket moved 8h before the report−103Olave back at practice,questionable for Saints at GiantsSat 12:00 PM+100NO RB Kamara activeSun 10:54 AM+104Price-only move+102Closing line+102
+108+104−100−104−108−113Opening line+108Market move, no reported newsWed 5:26 PM−111NYG RT Eluemunor ruled outSun 10:12 AM · market moved 5h before the report−106NO EDGE Broughton upgradedTue 11:21 AM · market moved 2h before the report−102NO LB Elliss upgradedTue 11:21 AM · market moved 2h before the report+101NO WR Olave questionableThu 5:09 PM−104NYG S Nubin ruled outThu 7:46 PM · market moved 22h before the report+100NO LB Elliss ruled outFri 7:01 AM · market moved 8h before the report−103Olave back at practice, questionable forSaints at GiantsSat 12:00 PM+100NO RB Kamara activeSun 10:54 AM+104Price-only move+102Closing line+102

Final: NO 34, NYG 27. Giants lost at a 50% closing chance to win.

Data
CauseWhenMove
Opening line48.0% (+108)
Market move, no reported newsWed Oct 7, 5:26 PM ET52.5% (−111)
NYG RT Eluemunor ruled outSun Oct 11, 10:12 AM ET51.5% (−106)
NO EDGE Broughton upgradedTue Oct 13, 11:21 AM ET50.4% (−102)
NO LB Elliss upgradedTue Oct 13, 11:21 AM ET49.7% (+101)
NO WR Olave questionableThu Oct 15, 5:09 PM ET51.0% (−104)
NYG S Nubin ruled outThu Oct 15, 7:46 PM ET49.9% (+100)
NO LB Elliss ruled outFri Oct 16, 7:01 AM ET50.8% (−103)
Olave back at practice, questionable for Saints at GiantsSat Oct 17, 12:00 PM ET49.9% (+100)
NO RB Kamara activeSun Oct 18, 10:54 AM ET49.0% (+104)
Price-only move49.6% (+102)
Closing line49.6% (+102)
What moved the totalConsensus over/under. Injuries on either side of the ball and weather move this line.
44454647Opening line44.5NYG S Nubin ruled outSun 6:31 PM+0.5Market move, no reported newsMon 11:19 AM+0.5NYG CB Newsome II questionableWed 9:48 PM+0.5NO WR Olave activeSun 12:57 PM+0.5Closing line46.5
44454647Opening line44.5NYG S Nubin ruled outSun 6:31 PM+0.5Market move, no reported newsMon 11:19 AM+0.5NYG CB Newsome II questionableWed 9:48 PM+0.5NO WR Olave activeSun 12:57 PM+0.5Closing line46.5

Final: NO 34, NYG 27. 61 points, over the closing total of 46.5.

Data
CauseWhenMove
Opening line44.5
NYG S Nubin ruled outSun Oct 11, 6:31 PM ET+0.5
Market move, no reported newsMon Oct 12, 11:19 AM ET+0.5
NYG CB Newsome II questionableWed Oct 14, 9:48 PM ET+0.5
NO WR Olave activeSun Oct 18, 12:57 PM ET+0.5
Closing line46.5

Notes

FinalSun Oct 18, 4:27 PM · NO

Saints Beat Giants 34–27 Despite McCarthy Starting

Final: New Orleans Saints 34, New York Giants 27. J.J. McCarthy started at quarterback for New York in place of Jameis Winston and went 11/21 for 243 yards, 1 touchdown and 1 interception. The closing line was Giants +1; New Orleans covered by 6. The 61 combined points went over the closing total of 46.5.

NO since this note: −1 → −1 (no move) at kickoff

RosterSun Oct 18, 4:44 PM · NYG

Giants pull Winston for McCarthy in loss to Saints

New York benched Jameis Winston after his second interception against New Orleans and turned to J.J. McCarthy at quarterback. The change raises questions about who starts for the Giants next week at Houston. CBS Sports

NYG since this note: +1 → +1 (no move) at kickoff

InjurySun Oct 18, 11:38 AM · NO

Saints rule out Elliss, Shepherd at Giants

New Orleans will be without linebacker Kaden Elliss and defensive lineman Nathan Shepherd for Sunday's game at the Giants. Both are front-seven regulars, weakening the Saints' run defense. New Orleans Saints (team site)

NO since this note: −1 → −1 (no move) at kickoff

RosterSun Oct 18, 9:37 AM · NYG

Harris set for bigger backfield share as Giants host Saints

A Sunday report says Najee Harris will take on a larger role in the Giants' running game against New Orleans. Cam Skattebo had led the backfield through five weeks, so the split could shift in Week 6. ProFootballTalk

NYG since this note: +0.5 → +1 (+0.5) at kickoff

MarketSun Oct 18, 12:02 PM · NYG

Line moves 1 toward the Saints ahead of the news

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from PK to +1 (home side), with 2 of 11 books moving the same way. The market started moving 2h 19m before the report: Alvin Kamara (RB) Questionable to Cleared.

NYG since this note: +0.5 → +1 (+0.5) at kickoff

MarketSun Oct 18, 11:11 AM · NYG

Line moves 1 on the news: Shough playing through two broken bones in non-throwing hand

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from PK to +1 (home side), with 2 of 11 books moving the same way. The move followed the report (possibly related): Shough playing through two broken bones in non-throwing hand.

NYG since this note: +0.5 → +1 (+0.5) at kickoff

InjurySun Oct 18, 7:33 AM · NO

Shough playing through two broken bones in non-throwing hand

Saints quarterback Tyler Shough has been playing with two fractures in his left, non-throwing hand. He is still expected to start, but the injury could affect ball handling and exchanges against the Giants. ESPN

NO since this note: −1 → −1 (no move) at kickoff

InjuryFri Oct 16, 6:15 PM · NO

Olave back at practice, questionable for Saints at Giants

Chris Olave practiced Friday after missing time with an illness and carries a questionable tag into Sunday's game at New York. His availability shapes the Saints' top passing option. ProFootballTalk

NO since this note: PK → −1 (−1.0) at kickoff

InjuryFri Oct 16, 4:32 PM · NYG

Carter practices, listed questionable for Giants-Saints

Giants pass rusher Abdul Carter returned to practice Friday and carries a questionable designation for Sunday against New Orleans. His return would boost a Giants pass rush that has been short-handed. ProFootballTalk

NYG since this note: PK → +1 (+1.0) at kickoff

MarketFri Oct 16, 7:40 AM · NYG

Line moves 1 toward the Giants with no reported news

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from +1 to PK (home side), with 1 of 11 books moving the same way. Neither team has reported news that explains it yet; moves like this often come before a story breaks.

NYG since this note: PK → +1 (+1.0) at kickoff

MarketFri Oct 16, 1:54 AM · NYG

Line moves 1 toward the Saints with no reported news

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from PK to +1 (home side), with 1 of 11 books moving the same way. Neither team has reported news that explains it yet; moves like this often come before a story breaks.

NYG since this note: +1 → +1 (no move) at kickoff

MarketThu Oct 15, 10:51 PM · NYG

Line moves 1 toward the Giants with no reported news

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from +1 to PK (home side), with 0 of 11 books moving the same way. Neither team has reported news that explains it yet; moves like this often come before a story breaks.

NYG since this note: PK → +1 (+1.0) at kickoff

MarketThu Oct 15, 8:10 PM · NYG

Line moves 1 toward the Saints with no reported news

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from PK to +1 (home side), with 1 of 11 books moving the same way. Neither team has reported news that explains it yet; moves like this often come before a story breaks.

NYG since this note: +1 → +1 (no move) at kickoff

InjuryThu Oct 15, 6:14 PM · NO

Olave sidelined again at Saints practice with illness

Saints top receiver Chris Olave missed practice for a second consecutive day Thursday due to an illness. His availability for Sunday at the Giants is in question, which would thin New Orleans' passing game. ProFootballTalk

NO since this note: PK → −1 (−1.0) at kickoff

MarketThu Oct 15, 7:43 PM · NYG

Line moves 1 toward the Giants ahead of the news (possibly related)

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from +1 to PK (home side), with 0 of 11 books moving the same way. The market started moving 1h 00m before the report (possibly related): Olave sidelined again at Saints practice with illness.

NYG since this note: PK → +1 (+1.0) at kickoff

MarketThu Oct 15, 7:27 PM · NYG

Line moves 1 toward the Saints ahead of the news (possibly related)

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from PK to +1 (home side), with 1 of 11 books moving the same way. The market started moving 1h 32m before the report (possibly related): Olave sidelined again at Saints practice with illness.

NYG since this note: +1 → +1 (no move) at kickoff

MarketThu Oct 15, 6:19 PM · NYG

Line moves 1 toward the Giants ahead of the news (possibly related)

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from +1 to PK (home side), with 0 of 11 books moving the same way. The market started moving 2h 34m before the report (possibly related): Olave sidelined again at Saints practice with illness.

NYG since this note: PK → +1 (+1.0) at kickoff

RosterThu Oct 15, 10:55 AM · NYG

Giants to keep McCarthy in change-of-pace role behind Winston

Giants coach Jim Harbaugh said McCarthy will continue to see snaps as a change-of-pace quarterback to use his mobility, with Jameis Winston remaining the starter. That means a split package at quarterback against New Orleans. ESPN player news

NYG since this note: +1 → +1 (no move) at kickoff

InjuryThu Oct 15, 9:12 AM · NO

Shough full practice as Saints point to Giants trip

Saints quarterback Tyler Shough took part fully in Thursday's practice ahead of the trip to New York. That points to him being available to start in Week 6. New Orleans Saints (team site)

NO since this note: −1 → −1 (no move) at kickoff

InjuryWed Oct 14, 4:31 PM · NYG

Carter sits out Giants' first practice of week

Giants pass rusher Abdul Carter did not practice Wednesday, putting his availability for Sunday's home game with New Orleans in question. He is a key part of New York's pass rush. ProFootballTalk

NYG since this note: +1 → +1 (no move) at kickoff

MarketTue Oct 13, 2:15 PM · NYG

Line moves 1 toward the Saints with no reported news

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from PK to +1 (home side), with 5 of 11 books moving the same way. Neither team has reported news that explains it yet; moves like this often come before a story breaks.

NYG since this note: +1 → +1 (no move) at kickoff

MarketMon Oct 12, 8:48 PM · NYG

Line moves 1 toward the Giants with no reported news

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from +1 to PK (home side), with 6 of 11 books moving the same way. Neither team has reported news that explains it yet; moves like this often come before a story breaks.

NYG since this note: +0.5 → +1 (+0.5) at kickoff

MarketMon Oct 12, 7:09 PM · NYG

Line moves 1.5 toward the Giants with no reported news

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from +1.5 to PK (home side), with 9 of 11 books moving the same way (a broad, fast move). Neither team has reported news that explains it yet; moves like this often come before a story breaks.

NYG since this note: +1 → +1 (no move) at kickoff

MarketMon Oct 12, 9:31 AM · NYG

Line moves 1 toward the Saints after last week's results

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from PK to +1 (home side), with 3 of 9 books moving the same way. The move began within hours of the teams' last games: the market re-rating them on what it just saw, not a news story.

NYG since this note: +1 → +1 (no move) at kickoff

MarketMon Oct 12, 1:41 AM · NYG

Line moves 1 toward the Saints after last week's results

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from −1 to PK (home side), with 7 of 9 books moving the same way (a broad, fast move). The move began within hours of the teams' last games: the market re-rating them on what it just saw, not a news story.

NYG since this note: PK → +1 (+1.0) at kickoff

MarketSun Oct 11, 9:55 PM · NYG

Line moves 2.5 toward the Giants after last week's results

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from +1.5 to −1 (home side), with 2 of 4 books moving the same way. The move began within hours of the teams' last games: the market re-rating them on what it just saw, not a news story.

NYG since this note: +1 → +1 (no move) at kickoff

WeatherTue Oct 13, 11:08 AM

Wind in the Forecast for Saints at Giants

The forecast for kickoff at MetLife Stadium calls for wind 12 mph, gusting 18. Forecasts change; this note updates as the game gets closer.

Total since this forecast: 44.5 → 46.5 (+2.0) at kickoff

MarketSun Oct 11, 11:38 PM · NYG

Line moves 2 toward the Giants ahead of the news

The consensus spread on Saints at Giants has moved from +1 to −1 (home side), with 8 of 8 books moving the same way (a broad, fast move). The market started moving 1h 43m before the report: Nathan Shepherd (DT) Questionable to Out.

NYG since this note: +1.5 → +1 (−0.5) at kickoff

Injury Report

New Orleans Saints

PlayerChangeWorthPlayed
DT Nathan Shepherd
Tue 1:37 PM
Out → Questionable−0.1 No
LB Kaden Elliss
Tue 1:37 PM
Out → Questionable−0.2 No
EDGE Vernon Broughton
Tue 1:37 PM
Out → Questionable−0.4 Yes
WR Chris Olave
Wed 4:49 PM
Active → Questionable+0.4 Yes
RB Alvin Kamara
Wed 5:50 PM
Active → Questionable+0.0 Yes
LB Kaden Elliss
Fri 3:15 PM
Questionable → Out+0.2 No
RB Alvin Kamara
Sun 11:40 AM
Questionable → Cleared−0.0 Yes
WR Chris Olave
Sun 11:50 AM
Questionable → Cleared−0.4 Yes
DT Nathan Shepherd
Sun 12:01 PM
Questionable → Out+0.1 No

New York Giants

PlayerChangeWorthPlayed
RT Jermaine Eluemunor
Sun 3:36 PM
Active → Questionable+0.2 No
S Tyler Nubin
Sun 3:47 PM
Active → Questionable+0.2 No
CB Greg Newsome II
Wed 5:09 PM
Active → Questionable+0.2 Yes
LT Andrew Thomas
Wed 5:09 PM
Active → Questionable+0.3 Yes
LB Abdul Carter
Wed 5:09 PM
Active → Questionable+0.2 Yes
WR Darnell Mooney
Wed 5:09 PM
Active → Questionable+0.1 Yes
S Tyler Nubin
Fri 5:39 PM
Questionable → Out+0.3 No
LB Abdul Carter
Sun 12:01 PM
Questionable → Cleared−0.2 Yes
RT Jermaine Eluemunor
Sun 12:06 PM
Questionable → Out+0.3 No
LT Andrew Thomas
Sun 12:06 PM
Questionable → Cleared−0.3 Yes

Worth = points against the team from that change in his chance of playing, on our valuation of him over his backup.

Every Book · Giants side

BookSpreadPriceMoneylineDecimalWin % (no-vig)TotalAs of
Consensus+1 −112−1081.93 49.6%46.5Sun 12:57 PM
KalshiPK —+1022.02 49.5%46Sun 12:57 PM
DraftKings+1.5 −125−1121.89 50.4%46.5Sun 12:57 PM
FanDuel+1.5 −122−1061.94 49.6%45.5Sun 12:57 PM
BetMGM+1 −115−1021.98 49.3%46.5Sun 12:57 PM
Caesars+1.5 −122−1051.95 49.1%46.5Sun 12:57 PM
Fanatics+0.5 −110−1101.91 50.0%46.5Sun 12:57 PM
BetRivers+0.5 −110−1091.92 49.7%45.5Sun 12:57 PM
BetOnlinePK −110—— —46.5Sun 12:57 PM
Bovada+1 −115−1051.95 48.9%46Sun 12:57 PM
LowVig+1 −112—— —46.5Sun 12:57 PM
MyBookie−1 −110−1131.88 51.0%46.5Sun 12:57 PM
BetUSPK −110—— —46.5Sun 12:57 PM

Best for NO: Fanatics −0.5 (−110)Best for NYG: FanDuel +1.5 (−122)

Closing prices: the last quote before kickoff. Kalshi's percentage is its contract price; its odds are that price with no margin. The Saints side is the mirror image.